A great replacement for rouge. I bought this along with the luxi blue bar to replace tripoli as I am keen to use products that are safer and cleaner, but still perform well. These luxi polishing compounds are great. I got a really lovely polish on all my silver pieces, there was very little residue polish, and that was easily removed after a few minutes in the ultrasonic quick wash with warm water and soap. I definitely wont be going back to tripoli or rouge.